Difference between revisions of "Category:MARPA Working Group"

From Linked Earth Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
( Pages with a poll, Working Group )
(created page)
 
(→‎Sub-groups)
 
(33 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
  
 
== Overview ==
 
== Overview ==
−
In the Linked Earth context, a [[:Category:Working_Group|working group]] (WG) is a self-organized coalition of knowledgeable experts, whose activities are governed [[:Category:Working_Group|herewith]]. This page is dedicated to the discussion of data and metadata standards for '''coral archives''', and aims to formulate a set of recommendations for such a standard.
+
In the Linked Earth context, a [[:Category:Working_Group|working group]] (WG) is a self-organized coalition of knowledgeable experts, whose activities are governed [[:Category:Working_Group|herewith]]. This page is dedicated to the discussion of data and metadata standards for '''MARPA''' (marine annually-resolved proxy archives, including [[:Category:Coral | corals]], [[:Category:MolluskShells | mollusks]], and [[:Category:Sclerosponge | sclerosponges]]), and aims to formulate a set of recommendations for such a standard. Note that chronological aspects should be discussed within the [[:Category:Chronologies_Working_Group|Chronologies WG]].
−
 
+
−
This WG needs to work closely with other WGs, as constraints will vary by archive. Nevertheless, some aspects are common enough that it is worth pursuing some general recommendations, and devise ''ad hoc'' adjustments for individual archives if need be. It is recommended that every WG coordinator join this WG to keep track of discussions.
+
  
 

Members of 'MARPA Working Group'

 
__MEMBERS__
Line 11: Line 9:
  
 
We recommend that discussions focus on the following techniques, and explore potential commonalities.
 
We recommend that discussions focus on the following techniques, and explore potential commonalities.
 +
 +
[[File:MetadataDefinitions.png | 400px | thumb | right | Definition of essential, recommended, and desired metadata in the context of paleoclimate data standards]]
  
 
For each chronology type, we recommend:
 
For each chronology type, we recommend:
 
* structuring discussions around what scientific questions one would want to ask of the data
 
* structuring discussions around what scientific questions one would want to ask of the data
−
* listing essential, recommended, and optional information for:
+
* listing essential, recommended, and desired information for:
 
** the measurements themselves
 
** the measurements themselves
 
** any inference made from the measurements (e.g. calibration to temperature)
 
** any inference made from the measurements (e.g. calibration to temperature)
Line 21: Line 21:
 
* provide separate recommendations for new and legacy datasets
 
* provide separate recommendations for new and legacy datasets
  
−
== Polls ==
+
== Sub-groups ==
  
−
Here are polls that the group might want to consider:
+
=== Corals ===
 +
observations to describe:  
 +
* stable isotopes
 +
* trace elements
 +
* radiocarbon
  
 +
=== Sclerosponges ===
 +
 +
=== Mollusks ===
 +
 +
===Coralline Algae===
 +
 +
== MARPA Standards : Template 1st draft ==
 +
Below is a summarizing the metadata  from the [[File:MARPA_Template.xlsx | MARPA template]]. See the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}}|Discussion]] to comment on the template, fill out the table below, and vote on the polls.
 +
 +
See this [[Paleoclimate Data Standards | page]] for the definition of essential, recommended, and desired metadata for the standards developed by LinkedEarth.
 +
 +
=== Physical Sample metadata - [http://www.geosamples.org SESAR] ===
 +
 +
Note: Although the new release of the LinkedEarth ontology will include a PhysicalSample category, there are no formal ways to describe the samples beyond their name, the possibility to enter an IGSN number or a lab ID number, a [[:Property:CollectionMethod | Collection Method]], and where the sample is currently located.
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|-
 +
|+Metadata for the PhysicalSample
 +
|-
 +
! Metadata || Essential (E), Recommended (R), Desired (D) || Comments
 +
|-
 +
| Sample Name ||  ||
 +
|-
 +
| IGSN || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Parent IGSN ||  ||
 +
|-
 +
| Material || || According to [https://github.com/IGSN/metadata/wiki/IGSN-Descriptive-Metadata-Version-1.0 SESAR metatada], categorizes the material that composes to the sample (e.g., water, granite, tissue). Proposed classification: Biology
 +
|-
 +
| Field Name || || In the LinkedEarth Ontology, this would be the [[:Property:SensorSpecies (L) | SensorSpecies]] and [[:Property:SensorGenus (L) | SensorGenus]]
 +
|-
 +
| Classification || || e.g., Marobiology>coral
 +
|-
 +
| Sample description || || e.g., Scleractinian corals, core 236cm - 6 sections
 +
|-
 +
| Age (min/max) and associated units || || In the LinkedEarth framework, the minimum/maximum age is automatically calculated from the chronology information when a file is transformed into LiPD
 +
|-
 +
| Geological age || ||
 +
|-
 +
|CollectionMethod || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Size and associated units || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Latitude || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Longitude || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Elevation start || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Navigation Type || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Location description || || e.g., lagoon
 +
|-
 +
| Locality || || e.g., Vanua Balavu
 +
|-
 +
| Locality description || || e.g, North of Susui village on east side of exposed reef
 +
|-
 +
| Country || || e.g., Fiji
 +
|-
 +
| State/Province || ||
 +
|-
 +
| County || ||
 +
|-
 +
| City/Township || ||
 +
|-
 +
| Field program/Cruise || || e.g., Evohe 2004 Expedition
 +
|-
 +
| Collector/Chief Scientist || || e.g, Braddock K. Linsley
 +
|-
 +
| Collection date || || 4/11/04
 +
|-
 +
| Collection date precision || || day
 +
|-
 +
|Current archive || || Where the physical sample is currently curated. e.g., LDEO Core Repository
 +
|-
 +
|Current archive contact || || e.g., Braddock K. Linsley
 +
|}
 +
 +
=== Publication data ===
 +
 +
The proposed scheme is similar to the one proposed by LinkedEarth. See [[Cross Archive Metadata | this page]] for more information
 +
 +
=== Timeseries Data ===
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|-
 +
|+Matadata pertaining to time series data
 +
|-
 +
! Metadata || Essential (E)/Recommended (R)/Desired (D) || Comments
 +
|-
 +
| Raw data ||  || Raw measurements reported against depth in the archive
 +
|-
 +
| Monthly interpolated data ||  || [[:Category:MeasuredVariable (L) | measured variables]] (e.g., [[D18O]], [[D13C]], [[Sr/Ca]]) and/or [[:Category:InferredVariable (L) | inferred variables]] (e.g., [[Sea Surface Temperature]]) reported against the monthly age model
 +
|}
 +
 +
'''Note''': Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA Depth.png | thumb | right| 400px| Results of the poll run on Twitter from April 11th to 18th 2017]]
  
 
<poll>
 
<poll>
−
What is your favorite chronology poll?
+
For MARPA archives, should the position where the measurements was taken on the archive (i.e. depth) be:
−
A poll that is droll
+
Essential Metadata
−
A poll with a role
+
Recommended Metadata
−
A poll with a roll
+
Desired Metadata
 
</poll>
 
</poll>
  
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA RawMeasurements.png | thumb | right | 400px | Results of the poll placed on Twitter from April 20th to 27th 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
For MARPA archives, should the raw measurements (e.g., d18O, Sr/Ca,...) be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA InterpolatedChronologies.png | thumb | 400px | right | Results of the poll run on Twitter from April 14th to 21st 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
For MARPA archives, should the interpolated chronology be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
=== Measurement Metadata ===
 +
 +
==== Instrument Section ====
 +
 +
In the LinkedEarth ontology, this refers to the [[:Category:Instrument (L)|Instrument]].
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|-
 +
|+Metadata regarding the instrument
 +
|-
 +
! Metadata ||Essential (E)/ Recommended (R)/ Desired (D) || Comments
 +
|-
 +
| Instrument Type || || We created an ontology for the various types of instruments. It's set as the category for the page.
 +
|-
 +
| Instrument Name ||  || e.g., Micromass Optima gas-source-triple-collector
 +
|-
 +
| Method ||  || Name of the method or paper published about it. In the LinkedEarth framework, the method is described at the variable rather than the instrument level. This allows for multiple methods used on the same instrument since the method is related to the measurements rather than the tools.
 +
|-
 +
| Notes || || Additional information
 +
|-
 +
| Institution || || Name of the Laboratory that ran the samples. In LinkedEarth, this is achieved through the property [[:Property:HousedAt (L) | housedAt]] which links to a traditional wiki page. Information about the laboratory can be entered on this new page for general information
 +
|-
 +
| Creator || || In LinkedEarth, the [[:Property:Contributor (L) | contributors]] of the datasets are acknowledged of the datasets and should include the authors on the publication as well as anyone who has contributed to producing the data (e.g. lab managers and technicians not included in the publication).
 +
|-
 +
|contact info || ||contact email for the person in charge of the data. Contact information on the LinkedEarth database are set on the user profiles. Each user can choose which information to share with other LinkedEarth member. Visitors to the site (i.e., person not logged in) do not have access to profiles' information.
 +
|}
 +
 +
'''Note''': Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.
 +
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA Instrument.png | thumb | 400px | right| Results of the poll ran on Twitter between April 17th and 24th.]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
Should information  about the instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA IntrumentType.png | thumb | 400px | right | Results of the poll placed on Twitter from May 12th to 19th 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
Should the type of instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
Should the location of the instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA StandardMethod.png | thumb | 400px | right| Results of the poll placed on Twitter between April 24th and May 1st 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
Should the method (if standard) used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
[[ File:TwitterPoll MARPA NewMethod.png | thumb | 400px | right| Results of the poll placed on Twitter between April 24th and May 1st 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
Should the method (if new) used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
====Uncertainty ====
 +
 +
Discussion in the [[:Category:Uncertainty Working Group | Uncertainty working group]]
 +
 +
====Chronology ====
 +
 +
MARPA recommends to archive the methodology used to develop chronological information. Further discussion should be done in the [[:Category:Chronologies Working Group | chronology working group page]].
 +
 +
==== Climate Interpretation ====
 +
 +
For more information about climate interpretation in LinkedEarth (and [[Linked Paleo Data | LiPD]]), see this [[:Category:Interpretation (L) |page]].
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|-
 +
|+Metadata associated with the Climate Interpretation
 +
|-
 +
! Metadata || Essential(E)/Recommended(R)/Desired(D) || Comments
 +
|-
 +
| [[:Property:Name (L) | name]] || R ||
 +
|-
 +
| [[:Property:Detail (L) | detail]] || R ||
 +
|-
 +
| [[:Property:InterpretationReferences (L) | basis]] || D || A reference that serves as the basis for interpretation
 +
|-
 +
| [[:Property:InterpretationDirection (L) | Sign of the relation]] || R || 
 +
|}
 +
 +
'''Note''': Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll MARPA interpretation.png | thumb | right | 400px |Results of the poll placed on Twitter from April 20th to 27th 2017]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
For MARPA archives, should the ClimateInterpretation be:
 +
Essential Metadata
 +
Recommended Metadata
 +
Desired Metadata
 +
</poll>
 +
 +
== Polls ==
 +
 +
[[File:TwitterPoll CoralXRay.png|thumb|right|Results of the Twitter poll ran 3/16/17 to 3/23/17]]
 +
 +
<poll>
 +
For coral archives, should the x-ray pictures be included with the data?
 +
Essential
 +
Recommended
 +
Desired
 +
</poll>
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
 
<references \>
 
<references \>

Latest revision as of 21:09, 28 June 2017


Overview

In the Linked Earth context, a working group (WG) is a self-organized coalition of knowledgeable experts, whose activities are governed herewith. This page is dedicated to the discussion of data and metadata standards for MARPA (marine annually-resolved proxy archives, including corals, mollusks, and sclerosponges), and aims to formulate a set of recommendations for such a standard. Note that chronological aspects should be discussed within the Chronologies WG.

__MEMBERS__

Specific tasks

We recommend that discussions focus on the following techniques, and explore potential commonalities.

Definition of essential, recommended, and desired metadata in the context of paleoclimate data standards

For each chronology type, we recommend:

  • structuring discussions around what scientific questions one would want to ask of the data
  • listing essential, recommended, and desired information for:
    • the measurements themselves
    • any inference made from the measurements (e.g. calibration to temperature)
    • the underlying uncertainties, and what those numbers correspond to (e.g. 1-sigma or 2-sigma?)
  • provide an ideal data table for each type of observation, so the community knows what to report and how to report it.
  • provide separate recommendations for new and legacy datasets

Sub-groups

Corals

observations to describe:

  • stable isotopes
  • trace elements
  • radiocarbon

Sclerosponges

Mollusks

Coralline Algae

MARPA Standards : Template 1st draft

Below is a summarizing the metadata from the File:MARPA Template.xlsx. See the Discussion to comment on the template, fill out the table below, and vote on the polls.

See this page for the definition of essential, recommended, and desired metadata for the standards developed by LinkedEarth.

Physical Sample metadata - SESAR

Note: Although the new release of the LinkedEarth ontology will include a PhysicalSample category, there are no formal ways to describe the samples beyond their name, the possibility to enter an IGSN number or a lab ID number, a Collection Method, and where the sample is currently located.

Metadata for the PhysicalSample
Metadata Essential (E), Recommended (R), Desired (D) Comments
Sample Name
IGSN
Parent IGSN
Material According to SESAR metatada, categorizes the material that composes to the sample (e.g., water, granite, tissue). Proposed classification: Biology
Field Name In the LinkedEarth Ontology, this would be the SensorSpecies and SensorGenus
Classification e.g., Marobiology>coral
Sample description e.g., Scleractinian corals, core 236cm - 6 sections
Age (min/max) and associated units In the LinkedEarth framework, the minimum/maximum age is automatically calculated from the chronology information when a file is transformed into LiPD
Geological age
CollectionMethod
Size and associated units
Latitude
Longitude
Elevation start
Navigation Type
Location description e.g., lagoon
Locality e.g., Vanua Balavu
Locality description e.g, North of Susui village on east side of exposed reef
Country e.g., Fiji
State/Province
County
City/Township
Field program/Cruise e.g., Evohe 2004 Expedition
Collector/Chief Scientist e.g, Braddock K. Linsley
Collection date 4/11/04
Collection date precision day
Current archive Where the physical sample is currently curated. e.g., LDEO Core Repository
Current archive contact e.g., Braddock K. Linsley

Publication data

The proposed scheme is similar to the one proposed by LinkedEarth. See this page for more information

Timeseries Data

Matadata pertaining to time series data
Metadata Essential (E)/Recommended (R)/Desired (D) Comments
Raw data Raw measurements reported against depth in the archive
Monthly interpolated data measured variables (e.g., D18O, D13C, Sr/Ca) and/or inferred variables (e.g., Sea Surface Temperature) reported against the monthly age model

Note: Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.

Results of the poll run on Twitter from April 11th to 18th 2017
For MARPA archives, should the position where the measurements was taken on the archive (i.e. depth) be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 22:34, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 4031EF5F1002309E2C8C0506C001E912

Results of the poll placed on Twitter from April 20th to 27th 2017
For MARPA archives, should the raw measurements (e.g., d18O, Sr/Ca,...) be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 22:34, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 57FD6ED4F56F43510D303CB3ECE3D321

Results of the poll run on Twitter from April 14th to 21st 2017
For MARPA archives, should the interpolated chronology be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 22:34, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 97433E475D47EC838D4BDFDADE5A25B8

Measurement Metadata

Instrument Section

In the LinkedEarth ontology, this refers to the Instrument.

Metadata regarding the instrument
Metadata Essential (E)/ Recommended (R)/ Desired (D) Comments
Instrument Type We created an ontology for the various types of instruments. It's set as the category for the page.
Instrument Name e.g., Micromass Optima gas-source-triple-collector
Method Name of the method or paper published about it. In the LinkedEarth framework, the method is described at the variable rather than the instrument level. This allows for multiple methods used on the same instrument since the method is related to the measurements rather than the tools.
Notes Additional information
Institution Name of the Laboratory that ran the samples. In LinkedEarth, this is achieved through the property housedAt which links to a traditional wiki page. Information about the laboratory can be entered on this new page for general information
Creator In LinkedEarth, the contributors of the datasets are acknowledged of the datasets and should include the authors on the publication as well as anyone who has contributed to producing the data (e.g. lab managers and technicians not included in the publication).
contact info contact email for the person in charge of the data. Contact information on the LinkedEarth database are set on the user profiles. Each user can choose which information to share with other LinkedEarth member. Visitors to the site (i.e., person not logged in) do not have access to profiles' information.

Note: Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.


Results of the poll ran on Twitter between April 17th and 24th.
Should information about the instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:11, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 3FDE98A714384CD51BF044C4951826A3

Results of the poll placed on Twitter from May 12th to 19th 2017
Should the type of instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:11, 31 March 2017.
poll-id E485B580A9C07DA56BAE40404A421102

Should the location of the instrument used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:11, 31 March 2017.
poll-id B2174302AD78A999FF47C2A6930B0F39

Results of the poll placed on Twitter between April 24th and May 1st 2017
Should the method (if standard) used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:13, 31 March 2017.
poll-id F8D60CFA75FB37589DBEC95BDA7056B8

Results of the poll placed on Twitter between April 24th and May 1st 2017
Should the method (if new) used to generate data from MARPA archives be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:13, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 145D941B29FE0D4D7DFC71EED693C096

Uncertainty

Discussion in the Uncertainty working group

Chronology

MARPA recommends to archive the methodology used to develop chronological information. Further discussion should be done in the chronology working group page.

Climate Interpretation

For more information about climate interpretation in LinkedEarth (and LiPD), see this page.

Metadata associated with the Climate Interpretation
Metadata Essential(E)/Recommended(R)/Desired(D) Comments
name R
detail R
basis D A reference that serves as the basis for interpretation
Sign of the relation R

Note: Do not edit the polls (even for typos) once voting has started as it will reset the vote counts to zero. If a change needs to be made, make an annotation above the old poll (i.e., above the poll tags) and place the new poll below the first one.

Results of the poll placed on Twitter from April 20th to 27th 2017
For MARPA archives, should the ClimateInterpretation be:
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 23:26, 31 March 2017.
poll-id 887E09FC5E2E1313538732A03ABACCD2

Polls

Results of the Twitter poll ran 3/16/17 to 3/23/17
For coral archives, should the x-ray pictures be included with the data?
You are not entitled to vote.
You are not entitled to view results of this poll.
There were 5 votes since the poll was created on 17:16, 14 March 2017.
poll-id F3A482FD0BFCD0804BD8B50913B5D24E

References

This category currently contains no pages or media.

Retrieved from "https://wiki.linked.earth/wiki/index.php?title=Category:MARPA_Working_Group&oldid=73969"